Old Fashioned Oshkosh – Dockside Tavern Food & Spirits

This past Friday, my Friday friends and I were in search of a place to get ourselves an old fashioned, a decent meal and most importantly—a place to watch the Badgers game. We wanted there to be a crowd, but not so full that it was a disaster. We settled on Dockside—as their website advertised having a new menu and $4 Captains on Fridays. Done deal.
Dockside is a contemporary restaurant on the river with adequate (and always packed) seating outside during the short Wisconsin patio-season. Inside, there is a very nice center bar and the walls have a fair amount of TVs, perfect for March Madness.
Just as I was taking a seat at the bar, another patron ordered the Dockside Old Fashioned, which comes with Jim Beam. I noticed, that my brandy old fashioned was made almost identically, but from a different bartender. I like that—consistency.
Both bartenders started by adding a cherry, half a standard orange slice and a packet of sugar to the glass. Several shakes of bitters was then added to the glass, followed by three crushes using a wooden muddler. The first bartender then added a splash of soda and swirled the concoction; however, my bartender then added two shots of an unidentifiable rail brandy. Interestingly, she then “cleaned off” the muddler by spraying a small amount of soda onto the stick, washing it off into my drink. After she added ice and soda, she mixed it all together using a drink shaker. Lastly, she topped off the cocktail with a spear of olives.
I love the froth on top of the old fashioned. It’s always a sign of a good cocktail, even when you can’t see it being made. Each sip of the drink had the aroma of bitters that I love so much. It wasn’t too sweet nor did it taste too much of alcohol. The price was a bit steep at $4.50, but definitely warranted as it was a perfectly crafted cocktail with double shots of brandy and that lovely froth.
While I won’t be back for a Badgers game (or any sports affair), I would definitely go back for their old fashioned.
Rating (out of 5 olives)
Dockside Tavern Food & Spirits
425 Nebraska Street

About Author

Megan Sonicksen

Old Fashioned aficionado and blogger ignoramus at oldfashionedwisconsin.com. In love with all things that make Wisconsin unique, especially when garnished with an olive.

Leave A Reply